WEEKLY UPDATE · SAINT JAMES · SUFFOLK COUNTYSaint James: Homes Are Selling in 11 Days — But 21% of Sellers Already BlinkedStock imagery · not a listingTim Lupo ·
Saint James Is Moving — But 19% of Sellers Already Blinked
Dated: April 20 2026
Views: 6
Tim Lupo
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Saint James · Suffolk County market coverage
Saint James Is Moving — But 19% of Sellers Already Blinked
Tim's Take · Weekly
5
New
2
Under Contract
0
Sold
$685,000
Median Price
85
Avg DOM
2
Mo. Supply
The Hook: Something worth watching is happening in Saint James right now. Active inventory sits at 27 homes with a median ask of $849,939 — but nearly 1 in 5 sellers has already cut their price. That tension between seller ambition and buyer reality is the whole story this week.
The Local Read: With 2 months of supply and an average of 73 days on market, this isn't a panic situation — but it's not a feeding frenzy either. Homes are moving, just not instantly, and buyers know it. The ones coming through open houses near the Nissequogue River corridor and along the quieter cul-de-sacs off Lake Avenue are doing their homework. They're comparing, negotiating, and walking away from anything that feels overpriced. That 95.2% list-to-sale ratio tells me sellers *are* getting close to ask — but only when they're priced right from day one. The 85-day average sold DOM says the homes that chased the market paid for it in time, not necessarily in price. Smithtown School District continues to hold value here, but it's not doing the pricing work for you anymore.
The Advice Line: If you've been sitting on a Saint James listing or thinking about testing the market this spring, the window is open — but pricing strategy matters more than ever right now. Let's look at your specific numbers before you list — 631-708-4151.
---
*Tim Lupo, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson | EXIT Realty Edge*
*Data reflects Saint James activity for the week of April 12, 2026. Source: MLS. Not intended as legal or financial advice.*
From Tim
If anything in Saint James this week catches your eye — a new listing, a price cut, a pattern worth digging into — text or call me directly. I'm watching this market every day and can save you hours of independent research.
Tim Lupo
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Affiliated with EXIT Realty Edge · 631-730-5100
Timothy Lupo
Tim has dedicated his career to understanding the full landscape of real estate, from the practical needs of everyday living to the long-term opportunities of strategic investing. His background spans....
Latest Blog Posts
WEEKLY UPDATE · RONKONKOMA · SUFFOLK COUNTYRonkonkoma homes are selling for 105% of asking — and buyers are still showing up 🔥Stock imagery · not a listingTim Lupo
WEEKLY UPDATE · PATCHOGUE · SUFFOLK COUNTYPatchogue sellers are walking away with more than asking — 102% list-to-sale ratio this week 🔥Stock imagery · not a listingTim
WEEKLY UPDATE · BELLPORT · SUFFOLK COUNTYBellport just had 3 homes go under contract with zero new listings to replace them 👀Stock imagery · not a listingTim Lupo ·
OneKey® MLS required Copyright, Source of Data and Disclaimer for IDX display
Information Copyright 2026, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved.
The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the
